Increase Climbing Rating Importance for Races with Significant Climbs
Summary:
When calculating event ratings for races that include categorized climbs (Cat 4, Cat 3, Cat 2, Cat 1, or HC), the algorithm should place substantially more weight on a rider's climbing rating rather than relying heavily on TT and Endurance ratings. This would create more balanced competition in hilly/mountainous races.
Problem:
Currently, the event rating system appears to favor Time Trial and Endurance abilities in any longer race, even in races with significant climbing. This leads to several issues: Climbers with lower overall ratings but strong climbing abilities are placed in lower pens than appropriate. Larger/heavier riders with strong TT/Endurance ratings are placed in higher pens despite climbing limitations. Race predictions become inaccurate (predicting top-5 finishes for riders who realistically can't achieve this on climbs). Some riders avoid climbing-heavy races due to poor pen placement.
Proposed Solution:
While I understand some weighting already exists, I propose a more substantial emphasis on climbing rating. Significantly increase the importance of climbing rating whenever a race includes categorized climbs. Use the established climb categorization formula (distance × gradient²) to determine how much weight to give climbing ability: HC climbs (600+ points): Climbing rating becomes the primary factor. Cat 1 climbs (300-600 points): Climbing rating heavily weighted. Cat 2 climbs (150-300 points): Climbing rating substantially weighted. Cat 3 and 4 climbs: Proportionally weighted based on their points.
Example: The first climb in the Marathon route: 9.9km long and gradient of 5.7%. (9.95.75.7)=321 or Category 1
Benefits:
More accurate race predictions and event ratings. Improved racing experience as riders compete against others with similar climbing abilities. More participation in climbing-focused events. Better bot selection for riders to train and race with.
For races with multiple climbs, the cumulative impact should be considered when determining how heavily to weight climbing ability in the event rating.

Deleting as requested, and will track this issue under the other suggestion you raised!
-
Ryan Yates commented
Please delete this one. See the newer one!